Shame and Guilt: A World of Difference

Learning to distinguish between two powerful emotions - superficially very similar but in practice, very different - is essential not only for healthy self-esteem but for fulfilling interpersonal relationships.

Jill and Sharon (not their real names) worked on the same projects in close proximity to each other in a relatively small office. Their work was very pressured with one tight deadline to meet after another. Small wonder that the two of them were continually treading on each others toes and from time to time, the very palpable tension between them would boil over into heated arguments.

One day they had such a fierce confrontation that if they hadn't been the mature adults that they were, it might very easily have become physical.

The next day, Jill didn't report for duty. Neither was she at work on the following day - nor the one after that. When her boss and her fellow workers made enquiries, they discovered that for some time she had been suffering, on and off, from a serious illness that she had hidden from everyone.

When Sharon learned of this, she almost went out of her mind. The last spat between the two of them kept replaying itself in her head. Maybe she was responsible for the sudden deterioration in her co-worker's health? Even assuming that the disease had been afflicting Jill for a long time already, perhaps Sharon's biting sarcasm and the force of her anger had weakened Jill further and made the condition worse?

It took many soothing words, a great deal of patience and hours of gentle explanation on the part of Sharon's sympathetic but firm husband to get her eventually to snap out of her alternating hysteria and depression. He repeated over and over again that while the unkind words both Sharon and her colleague had hurled at each other were certainly not to be condoned, it was unreasonable and illogical to accept blame for Jill's deteriorating health.

Most importantly, explained Sharon's husband, the overpowering feeling of guilt that was driving her to distraction every moment of the day was preventing her from functioning properly and was serving no one's interests - not hers and certainly not Jill's.

I recently wrote a short article that I called Shame Should Be a Badge of Honor, which somehow hit a raw nerve for many and attracted a lot of interest. I decried the lack of healthy shame in today's society, a lack which leads to people committing dishonest, indecent, immoral and unethical acts under the public gaze in broad daylight without as much as batting an eyelid.

In it's purest form, shame is a positive, healthy phenomenon. It is rooted in the desire for self-improvement and involves working with the intellect. It's all about personal responsibility, and is an elevating experience that provides an impetus for growth and promotes human dignity. It ultimately leads to enhanced interpersonal relationships.

Irrational Guilt, on the other hand - in the sense that I'm talking about here - is not about self-control, but rather the reverse. It's a debilitating and even crippling experience that erodes self-esteem and has no positive outcome. It's not about the intellect. It's about the heart ruling the head in the most negative sense.

In the end, rather than bringing people closer to their fellows, it creates barriers between them. This is surely a point of crucial significance.

In practice, how do we ensure that positive shame will never degenerate into irrational guilt? Sometimes it's far from easy, as we see from Sharon's unfortunate episode. In extreme cases, professional help may be required, especially when recurring guilt feelings are precipitated by one or more traumatic incidents in a person's past life.

Generally speaking, though, there's one yardstick that's useful in many different situations in determining whether a certain feeling, state of mind, or attitude is positive and constructive or unhealthy and destructive. What we have to look at ourselves in the mirror and ask ourselves the following question:

"Honestly, what's motivating me? Is it my ego or am I motivated by a sincere interest in the the party I'm involved with or in the people around me?"

Azriel Winnett is creator of Hodu.com - Your Communication Skills Portal. This popular free website helps you improve your communication and relationship skills in your business or professional life, in the family unit and on the social scene. New articles added almost daily. Visit Azriel's blog at: http://hodu.com/blog.

In The News:


Boston Globe

A ball of inspirational predictability
Surrey Now,  Canada - 14 hours ago
... Gary Fleder's extensive use of close-ups. Inspirational? Check. Predictable? Yep. But The Express is a safe bet for sports fans and non-cynics alike.
Football drama a genuine inspirational tale Chicago Daily Herald
The Express Box Office Prophets
Review: The Express College Times
Baltimore Sun - UrbanMeccaall 438 news articles

Calgary Herald

A new generation of icky, angsty, inspirational books for teens ...
Calgary Herald,  Canada - 19 hours ago
Sure, they text and they Twitter and they play way too much Wii. But all those twitchy, tormented adolescent souls are still able to lose--and then ...

A new generation of icky, angsty, inspirational books for teens ...
Calgary Herald,  Canada - 20 hours ago
by Hunter S. Thompson In high school my best buddy Gavin and I fancied ourselves literary snobs. We read Dostoevsky--he was our favourite--and Tolstoy and ...

Inspirational Speaker Teaches Students the Value of “Zing!”
St. John's University, NY - 13 hours ago
... Your Influence and was featured in the motivational speaker compilation Lessons from the Road: Inspirational Insights by Leading Speakers in Education. ...

'Without a Quarter in My Pocket': New Memoir Chronicles Cuban ...
MarketWatch - Oct 8, 2008
SALEM, Ill., Oct 08, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Dr. Secundino E. Rubio's life is a series of inspirational stories. From his childhood in pre-Castro ...

Concert event was inspirational
Packet Online, NJ - Oct 9, 2008
Having the world-renowned recorder player from the Netherlands, Marion Verbruggen, appear the Slowdown Café in Hightstown in a concert with full proceeds to ...

Demure look for inspirational Helen
The Press Association - Oct 8, 2008
Actress Dame Helen Mirren looked unusually demure when she collected an award for her fashion sense. Dame Helen, who is known for her love of revealing ...

‘Inspirational’ visit to North Wales
Daily Post, UK - Oct 9, 2008
Speaking to the Daily Post last night, he said his North Wales visits had been “inspirational.” The Time to Talk – Time to Listen Tour is into its second ...

Strategies: Eleanor Roosevelt's story inspires, especially now
USA Today - 23 hours ago
One of the most inspirational leaders of that time is one of my role models: first lady Eleanor Roosevelt. Because this week marks the anniversary of ...

Washington Post

Obama Asks Supporters to 'Believe'
Washington Post, United States - Oct 8, 2008
By Robert Barnes INDIANAPOLIS -- Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama followed last night's debate with a confident and inspirational speech that ...
Video: Obama, McCain Trade Jabs on Economy, Open Debate AssociatedPress
On Politics: Will war of words explode at Belmont? Nashville City Paper
Kenya: Gloves Off As McCain And Obama Set for Debate AllAfrica.com
Washington Postall 2,657 news articles
inspirational - Google News

The Great Challenge of Life

Here's the great challenge of life - You can have... Read More

Anam Chara - Healing the Heart Matters

Are you prepared to make your heart matter? Are you... Read More

Forcing Inspiration

Most people, when they have to complete a creative endeavour,... Read More

The True and Magnificent Power of Giving

You've probably heard of the popular saying "It's better to... Read More

The Spectacular You

I recently received a letter addressed to Spectacular Rachelle Lee.... Read More

Whats Simple?

If you walk up to a stranger in the grocery... Read More

Forgiveness

"If unresolved anger is a toxin to the spirit, forgiveness... Read More

Starting A New Disaster Relief Program

I believe that it is an amazing time in our... Read More

Taking Life Head On

"We are built to conquer environment, solve problems, achieve goals... Read More

Weapons of Mass Distraction

Anything that draws one away from the business of living... Read More

Lifetime of Discoveries: Moments of Peace and Renewal

There are discoveries all around us—small gifts of joy that... Read More

H-U-G-S -------The More You Give----The More You Get!

How many of us couldn't use a hug on a... Read More

You Are a Beautiful Person

I wish that I could tell every person that I... Read More

Dreams and Desires, Wants and Wishes Journals

Have you ever dreamed of a new house? Have you... Read More

The Climbs In Our Lives

I grew up climbing mountains. Mountains are beautiful and challenging,... Read More

Duplicity

Direct Answers - Column for the week of January 26,... Read More

As A Caterpillar

"Happiness can be as elusive as a fluttering butterlfy but... Read More

Good Morning... Please...Thank-you!!

When I was a child, I remember that my parents... Read More

Are You Afraid of Change?

Change, no matter how you cut it, can certainly be... Read More

Life Is Worthwhile If You

(Excerpted from the Jim Rohn Two Day Weekend event -... Read More

Basic Buddhism - Doing What is Right

I find of particular interest in the Eastern Religions many... Read More

8 Ways to Get Your Healthy Groove On

You've heard the saying, "You are what you eat." I... Read More

Wanna Trade Places?

Even immediately after my car accident, every single person who... Read More

How Four Words Can Enhance Your Life Of Prayer (Pray More In My Hectic Day? You Cant Be Serious)

"I would like to pray more. But ... how to... Read More

Everyone Has Been Hurt... Part 4

Continued...After that I stayed with him still and when he... Read More